Values have dependencies

I’ve been thinking about European values, and what it actually takes to maintain them.

I like living in a society that tries to give people a reasonable starting point. That allows a lot of individual freedom, and provides some support when things go wrong. We can argue about how well we do any of that. But broadly, I think these are worthwhile things to organise around.

They also have fairly extensive dependencies.

A functioning welfare state requires productive businesses, tax collection, competent institutions and people who know how to run them. Access to your money requires payment systems. Access to public services increasingly requires digital identity. All of these depend on electricity, communications, software and a lot of coordination.

If we want to preserve the outcomes, we need to understand what produces them.

This seems obvious from an engineering perspective. You can’t judge a system’s reliability by looking only at the part the user interacts with. You have to look at what it depends on, and what happens when those dependencies fail.

I think we could apply more of that thinking to the things we want to preserve about Europe.

Donella Meadows makes a useful distinction in Thinking in Systems: stability and resilience are different properties. Something can behave consistently for a long time while having very little capacity to recover from a change in its environment.

That is easy to miss. If a system keeps working, the assumptions behind it rarely demand your attention. You can spend years improving it without testing what happens when one of those assumptions stops holding.

Take communication. Having several apps available looks like having options. But if they all require the same unavailable connection, switching apps doesn’t help much. The relevant question is how far down the alternatives remain independent.

There is a geopolitical version of this problem too. We built many of our dependencies around a relatively cooperative world order. Russia’s war in Ukraine, the war with Iran, and the US’s willingness to put longstanding relationships under pressure make that assumption increasingly difficult to maintain.

Interdependence changes when countries become more willing to use it against one another. The infrastructure can remain exactly the same while the conditions under which we get to use it change substantially.

Complete independence doesn’t strike me as realistic or particularly desirable. But we need to pay attention to how mutual these dependencies actually are. What do we need from others? What do they need from us? And what options remain if they decide that cooperation no longer serves their interests?

This is where I think we’re falling short. Much of what we’ve built in Europe is worth protecting. But I don’t think we’re doing enough to remain capable of protecting it. Our ability to maintain our values depends partly on our ability to build useful things, remain economically relevant and keep essential systems running.

My interest in this is partly personal. My first computer came from the municipality of Amsterdam because my mother was receiving benefits. That gave me access to something I would eventually build my career around. It’s a concrete example of what I think we get right: giving someone an opportunity their circumstances wouldn’t otherwise provide.

I want us to remain capable of doing that. Through working on Kieskompas, and later in finance, I’ve had some exposure to the systems that let people participate in society. It’s also where I think I could contribute most usefully.

I wrote earlier that understanding a technology creates some responsibility for what happens with it. I think that applies to the systems we already rely on too. If you understand a dependency and its failure modes, you’re in a relatively good position to help improve it.

One thing I’d like to investigate is neighbourhood communication during prolonged electricity and network outages. Start with one area in Amsterdam, together with a municipality or safety region, and work out what would actually be useful.

Who needs to reach whom? What equipment would they need? How is it powered? Can people use it without the person who built it standing next to them? Who maintains it between tests?

I don’t know yet which approach makes the most sense. There are technical and organisational questions here, and I’d expect the organisational ones to take a substantial part of the work.

But it’s a bounded problem we can investigate and test. I’d like to find out what it would take to get a first trial running.